Glossary entry (derived from question below)
English term or phrase:
hospitals a Dr. attends
English answer:
hospitals where a physician practices
Added to glossary by
jerrie
Jul 9, 2004 06:00
19 yrs ago
English term
hospitals a Dr. attends
English
Other
Medical (general)
medicine
does it sound natural to use that phrase ? I want to refer to hospitals a Dr. works.
Responses
+9
23 mins
Selected
practices / practises
You could use practice / practise to describe a doctors work...
Hospitals where a doctor practises
Hospitals where a doctor practises
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "Graded automatically based on peer agreement."
+1
14 mins
hospitals where the DR. works
Agree, you can use it, althuough not very much used in USA.
Peer comment(s):
neutral |
Krisztina Lelik
: MD and not Dr is used in English
8 mins
|
agree |
DGK T-I
: but disagree Krisztina's comment:MD is the standard US degree for medical doctors, but not for UK medical doctors (there MD is a postgraduate research degree undertaken by medical doctors) eg:'attending'http://www.rwh.org.au/cacwh/projects.cfm?doc_id=4296
15 hrs
|
+4
56 mins
physician
It is preferrable to use physician instead of doctor.
*the hospital (which) a physician is affiliated with* might be a good solution
Often a physician has a private practice, but is connected with a hospital, where he refers his patient when they require hospitalization. He then treats his patients in that hospital.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 hr 9 mins (2004-07-09 07:10:02 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
I would say that a physician attends patients, or attends meetings, seminars etc. but works in, practices in, is affiliated with, or is a consultant at a hospital.
*the hospital (which) a physician is affiliated with* might be a good solution
Often a physician has a private practice, but is connected with a hospital, where he refers his patient when they require hospitalization. He then treats his patients in that hospital.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 hr 9 mins (2004-07-09 07:10:02 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
I would say that a physician attends patients, or attends meetings, seminars etc. but works in, practices in, is affiliated with, or is a consultant at a hospital.
Peer comment(s):
agree |
lindaellen (X)
1 hr
|
agree |
Vicky Papaprodromou
4 hrs
|
agree |
jccantrell
: My wife, the doctor, speaks of 'attending physician' all the time. So it is used in the USA.
7 hrs
|
agree |
DGK T-I
: Agree.gen (Phys-US) (Neut.JC's comment: agreeJC-physicians/doctors attending might be fine,but asker should be wary using'attending physician'(apparently consultant rank http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=16...
15 hrs
|
Dear Dr. G.K. - Please don't use a neutral to comment on a peer comment unless it is meant for the posted answer as well, in which case, please indicate what you are neutral about. // thanks!!
|
+1
1 day 5 hrs
Comment
to clarify to the Asker:
my 2 neutrals above
are not
neutrals (or criticisms of)
German & Armaat's answers.
Obviously,
that was why they said "to X's comment" and "re.Y's comment"
(which shows that they were not 'neutrals' to the answerer's answers, but I'll make it clearer, in case it helps...)
For German's answer the neutral was ONLY to K's point about titles for doctors (which, with apologies to K I disagree with).
I gave an Australian reference supporting German's answer, and I do NOT disagree with it.
For Armaat's answer too,
the neutral was ONLY about C's comment (I agree with what C says) to warn the asker that it might be important to be careful about using "attending physician" because, according to the BMJ, it's a particular high rank of physician. It seemed to me that the asker might find that useful information in the translation, in some circumstances, and since it arose out of the comment, it seemed the best place to put it.
Armaat does NOT suggest using "attending physician" but "physician attending",
so Armaat's answer might be fine, as I said.
It does seem that 'Physician' seems to be popular in the US for various sorts of doctor, eg: http://www.medword.com/MedwordStore/PersonalEdge/faq-code.ht... (in the UK physicians are specifically the non-surgical branch of hospital doctors).
I agree with C's comment supporting Armaat's answer (showing that 'attending, etc' are used).
(just to avoid any misunderstanding or offence,
and to clarify for the asker, if there is any doubt!)
All 3 answers (German, Jerrie, Armaat) take sensible approaches, and (to some extent) I would want to know the country and have a few sentences before choosing.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 day 6 hrs 1 min (2004-07-10 12:02:11 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
(Armaat isn\'t talking about using attending for hospitals, and suggests some other solutions in different situations - they\'re all acceptable)
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 day 6 hrs 3 mins (2004-07-10 12:04:28 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
(So are the other answers)
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 day 6 hrs 51 mins (2004-07-10 12:52:14 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
(And I hope no one is offended, or still feels their answer was being criticized!)
my 2 neutrals above
are not
neutrals (or criticisms of)
German & Armaat's answers.
Obviously,
that was why they said "to X's comment" and "re.Y's comment"
(which shows that they were not 'neutrals' to the answerer's answers, but I'll make it clearer, in case it helps...)
For German's answer the neutral was ONLY to K's point about titles for doctors (which, with apologies to K I disagree with).
I gave an Australian reference supporting German's answer, and I do NOT disagree with it.
For Armaat's answer too,
the neutral was ONLY about C's comment (I agree with what C says) to warn the asker that it might be important to be careful about using "attending physician" because, according to the BMJ, it's a particular high rank of physician. It seemed to me that the asker might find that useful information in the translation, in some circumstances, and since it arose out of the comment, it seemed the best place to put it.
Armaat does NOT suggest using "attending physician" but "physician attending",
so Armaat's answer might be fine, as I said.
It does seem that 'Physician' seems to be popular in the US for various sorts of doctor, eg: http://www.medword.com/MedwordStore/PersonalEdge/faq-code.ht... (in the UK physicians are specifically the non-surgical branch of hospital doctors).
I agree with C's comment supporting Armaat's answer (showing that 'attending, etc' are used).
(just to avoid any misunderstanding or offence,
and to clarify for the asker, if there is any doubt!)
All 3 answers (German, Jerrie, Armaat) take sensible approaches, and (to some extent) I would want to know the country and have a few sentences before choosing.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 day 6 hrs 1 min (2004-07-10 12:02:11 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
(Armaat isn\'t talking about using attending for hospitals, and suggests some other solutions in different situations - they\'re all acceptable)
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 day 6 hrs 3 mins (2004-07-10 12:04:28 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
(So are the other answers)
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 day 6 hrs 51 mins (2004-07-10 12:52:14 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
(And I hope no one is offended, or still feels their answer was being criticized!)
Peer comment(s):
agree |
Melanie Nassar
: thanks for clarifying. I'm never offended by peer comments, and think we need more and bolder ones sometimes, but I do believe mine is the most correct answer, and a neutral detracts, no matter how you explain it. I really don't know the solution.
7 days
|
Perhaps the neutrals did psychologically discourage readers, so that they didn't fully consider the details of all answers, and that the neutrals were to the comments rather than the answers. I've done my best to add some blue to rectify this :-)
|
+1
2 days 15 hrs
hospital where the physician has priviledges or is an attending physician
An attending physician is actually on staff at the hospital (i.e. the hospital pays him;her). A physician who has priviledges can have his or her patients admitted to that hospital and treat them there.
Peer comment(s):
agree |
DGK T-I
: agree with this for the US, ('attending physician' seems to be senior rank) http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=16... (do both together include all hosp.drs inUS,including junior? -genuine question,I don't know)
3 days 19 hrs
|
Something went wrong...