Glossary entry

Spanish term or phrase:

la tópica

English translation:

topos / topoi

Added to glossary by Evan Tomlinson
Jul 7, 2014 04:00
9 yrs ago
4 viewers *
Spanish term

la tópica

Spanish to English Social Sciences Philosophy Logic
Context: "Como lógica predominantemente formal no enseña sólo la manera de alcanzar el saber de lo necesario, sino de regular el carácter dialogante del hombre. Sólo así, el diálogo deja de ser un parloteo de loros. La racionalidad de lo social a partir de convicciones comunes es el tema de la tópica."

The general context is a discussion of the subject matter of Aristotle's logical treatise The Topics. Here it is not a question of the title of the book, but rather the name for the "items" that the book studies. I have seen these called alternately "topics" and "commonplaces".

I originally was going to use "topics", but it seems to me that what Aristotle is talking about is not precisely the same thing that we mean in English when we say "topics". However, the term "commonplaces" is awkward and a bit odd to my ears. However, I am not a specialist in either logic or rhetoric, so I am not a good judge.
Proposed translations (English)
4 +2 topos / topoi

Proposed translations

+2
3 hrs
Selected

topos / topoi

"Topic" is actually quite correct for this. In philosophical discourse, the kind of arguments Aristotle is discussing in this work can properly be called "topics". You are quite right, however, that "topic" in modern English comes with another common meaning attached (an issue or subject) and that this could cause confusion among some readers.

The solution that is often adopted is to use the Greek term "topos", plural "topoi". It is standard in the academic study of literature for a commonplace theme or formula (known as a "tópico" in Spain), and is very commonly used by professional philosophers when discussing this subject in Aristotle, as I think the following results illustrate:

https://www.google.es/search?num=100&site=&source=hp&q=Arist...

The advantage, of course, is that it's accurate but no one will mistake its meaning, as could happen with the English term "topics".

So what about endoxa? It's a very closely related concept, and is certainly part of Aristotle's terminology, but it's not exactly the same thing, and in this field small differences matter. Endoxa are commonly held opinions. Topics or topoi are arguments resting on such opinions. Endoxa are premises; topoi are arguments.

Here's an expression of this in Spanish:

"Por todo ello parece acertado decir, con Bornscheuer, que en Aristóteles topoi y endoxa designan diferentes aspectos de la misma cosa: el concepto de topos remite al carácter instrumental de todo punto de vista argumentativo generalmente aplicable, mientras que el concepto de endoxa se refiere al momento del reconocimiento social general de tales puntos de partida."
http://books.google.es/books?id=wjwkQHrRIMMC&pg=PA59&lpg=PA5...

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 3 hrs (2014-07-07 07:31:55 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

And here is valuable confirmation from Robin Smith, Professor of Philosophy at Texas A&M and author of the standard modern commentary on Aristotle's Topics (Oxford: Clarendon, 1997):

"These collections of endoxa will be useful for telling us whether our opponent will accept any given premiss, but they will not of themselves tell us which premisses to put forward. That is the job of a second component of the dialectical art, one that is far more significant for the history of philosophy and logic: the collection of topoi, 'places' or 'locations'. [...]
What, then, are these 'locations', these topoi, which give the Topics its name? Unfortunately, the Topics itself does not tell us in so many words. However, Aristotle does say that the internal Books II-VII of the Topics consist of topoi".
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Topics-Books-VIII-Clarendon-Aristotl...

You can use Amazon's "Look Inside" feature to browse this book.
Peer comment(s):

agree Neil Teixeira (X)
50 mins
Thanks, Neil :)
agree lorenab23 : Yes :-)
20 hrs
Many thanks, Lorena :)
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanks, your answer was very helpful"
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search